Can Vertical Disc Herniation Cause Pain?
Although Schmorl’s nodes in the past have been considered clinically insignificant, clearly they can be an active symptom or cause of pain in some patients.
Schmorl’s nodes refer to protrusions of intervertebral disc cartilage through vertebral body endplate and into the adjacent vertebra. (Figure 1.) Lateral herniations that impinge spinal roots are more commonly expected. But Schmorl’s node herniations are vertical.
These vertebral herniations, named after German pathologist Christian Georg Schmorl (1861–1932)—also called intravertebral disc herniations or Schmorl nodes—are distinguished from bone infection and malignancy. However, comorbidities should not be overlooked. Hypothetically, a patient with a history of Schmorl’s nodes could contract an infection that leads to vertebral osteomyelitis. Disc herniation may also be complicated by unrelated tumor growth.
Protrusions can contact the marrow of the vertebra, possibly leading to inflammation or remain asymptomatic. The protrusions are also associated with necrosis of the vertebral bone. Whether this prolapse and inflammation cause the necrosis, or whether the cartilage migrates into areas that have become necrotic due to other conditions, is under investigation. Forces normally distributed by the nucleus pulposus (the incompressible gelatinous center of the intervertebral disc) are concentrated in a certain area causing endplates to deform in a concave manner.
Although Schmorl’s nodes in the past have been considered clinically insignificant, clearly they can be an active symptom or cause of pain in some patients. T.R. Yochum states that Schmorl’s nodes may be caused by numerous factors: trauma; hyperparathyroidism; osteoporosis; Schuermann’s disease; osteomalacia; infections; and neoplasm. According to pathogenesis of 12 surgical specimens by B. Peng, vertebral marrow cavities (less often seen in X-rays) are not empty, but an ingrowth of fibrous tissue or fibrocartilage from the necrotic area into the cartilaginous endplate.
The hypotheses of Schmorl’s nodes origin and pathogenesis include developmental factors, degenerative conditions, pathological processes such as infection, neoplasia and trauma. Studies have demonstrated that nucleus pulposis activates the release of inflammatory hormones and enzymes (such as leukotrenes, cytokines, PLA2, substance P, etc.), and as such may be responsible for C-nociception or diffuse vertebrogenic pain. Peng suggests that Schmorl’s nodes are the end result of ischaemic necrosis beneath the cartilaginous endplate and that herniation into the body of the vertebra is secondary.
Does It Hurt?
In symptomatic patients, the vertebral body marrow surrounding the Schmorl’s node gives a low signal intensity on T1-weighted and a high signal intensity on T2-weighted images. This indicates the presence of inflammation and edema within the vertebral bone marrow. These MRI findings were not present in asymptomatic individuals which suggested that Schmorl’s nodes became asymptomatic when the inflammation subsided.
F.M.K. Williams and colleagues note that Schmorl’s nodes etiological significance for back pain may be due to lumbar disc disease, as the two commonly occur simultaneously. N.S.M. Neves, et al. reports significantly decreased pain following percutaneous biopsy revealing fibrocartilaginous fragments, similar to intervertebral disc, with no signs of a malignant or infectious process. Schmorl’s nodes are better identified on CT images, and best seen on MRI. (Figure 2.) Acute herniation can appear more aggressive with surrounding bone marrow edema and peripheral enhancement. If pain is present, it can last a few years before subsiding.
There is case reported by Seon Joo Park, Ph.D, et al. of complete separation of a vertebral body caused by an untreated Schmorl’s node accompanying severe osteoporosis. Active herniation can increase the risk of vertebral fractures by about 10 percent. Vertebroplasty may be an effective remedy, especially when found with osteoporosis.
- Schmorl nodes. radiopaedia.org
- Schmorl’s nodes. wikipedia.org
- Schmorl’s Nodes, Back Pain, and MRI—Clinically Significant or Insignificant? David BenEliyahu. dynamicchiropractic.com
- The pathogenesis of Schmorl’s nodes, David BenEliyahu. boneandjoint.org.uk
- The Several Faces of Schmorl’s Node: Pictorial Essay, 2015. scielo.br
- Symptomatic giant Schmorl’s node treated by a decompression procedure. N.S.M. Neves, et al. sciencedirect.com
- Complete Separation of the Vertebral Body Associated with a Schmorl’s Node Accompanying Severe Osteoporosis. europepmc.org
- Main image of man in back pain licensed from Adobe Stock.
- Figure 2 vertebrae illustration ©2017 Kevin RR Williams